Hot pour-over coffee, 12 oz, $3

Our beans are roasted once a week by Heartwood Roastery (Burton, Ohio), and ground to order by us! (Food and Wine Magazine recently rated Heartwood’s beans as one of the best in the state. Not bad!)

Dark roast

Old River (Colombia) – Caramel, dark chocolate, bold

Medium roast

Colombia (Colombia) – Caramel, orange, nice body

Birdseye (Ethiopia and Colombia) – Green apple, cocoa, balanced

Light roast

Ask about our featured beans!


Medium roast, Swiss-water processed Arabica beans


Add-ons include:

* Cream: Half-and-half, almond milk, coconut milk

* Organic Monin syrups: Butter Pecan, Caramel, Chocolate, Hazelnut, Irish Cream, Vanilla

* Mocha recipe: Ghirardelli hot chocolate mix

* Sweeteners: Organic stevia, white cane sugar, sugar-in-the-raw, un-pasteurized honey

* Organic powdered cinnamon and nutmeg, Ghirardelli cocoa powder, cinnamon sticks


Cold-brew coffee, 16 oz, $3

Our 12-hour cold-brew coffee features a medium-roast bean (Birdseye, listed above). Order yours black, or with any of the accessories listed above.


More Hot Beverages


Hot chocolate, 12 oz, $3

Super yummy Ghirardelli hot chocolate! Consider adding half-and-half plus a shot of organic Monin cherry syrup to create a Black Forest-style drink.


Apple cider, 12 oz, $3

Add a half-shot of caramel syrup to create what tastes like a caramel-covered apple. Or add a shake of organic cinnamon powder, or a whole cinnamon stick!




Hot tea, 12 oz, $3

Organic, fair trade, kosher tea in unbleached bags from Old Familiar Ways (Fairport Harbor, Ohio).


Blossoms of Health – Delicate floral/green scent

Cold and Flu – Take care of yourself!

Mint – Revitalizing flavor, mild mint notes

Red Rooibos – Aromatic, high in antioxidants

Soul Calming – Calms nerves, settles stomach



Classic Chai – Black Darjeeling, warm spices

Earl Grey – Fermented black tea, bergamot
Mint Chocolate Maté – Earthy, refreshing

Oolong – Semi-fermented green and black teas

Orange/Ginger/Peach – with a green tea base


Cold-brew tea, 16 oz, $3


Lemon ginger – Refreshing probiotic



Unsweetened black – Orange pekoe blend


Sweeten with stevia, organic white cane sugar, sugar-in-the-raw, agave, local un-pasteurized honey.

Half-and-half, almond milk, or coconut milk.


More Cold Beverages


Smoothies, 16 ounce, $4

We serve Monin Fruit Smoothie Mixes, which are made with naturally sweetened real fruit juice and zero preservatives. Choose from Mango, Peach, Strawberry, Strawberry/Banana, and Wildberry.


Italian sodas, 16 ounce, $3

Inspired by traditional Italian Soda recipes, these fruity/floral drinks are made with carbonated water, cream, and syrups: Butter Pecan, Caramel, Cherry, Chocolate, Habanero, Hazelnut, Irish Cream, Lavender, Lemon, Lime, Raspberry, Rose, and Vanilla.


Bottles and Cans


Bubly, 12 ounce can, $1

Sparkling water, no sugar at all. Choose from Cherry, Grapefruit, Lemon, Lime, Mango, or Orange.


Distillata spring water, 16.9 ounce, $1

Providing bottled water to Cleveland and Akron since 1897.


Classic Bakery


Large pastries, $3.50

Loaves (seasonal), rolls, buns, bars, brownies, cobblers (seasonal). From local baker Kate Schultz of The Baker’s Rack (Perry, OH).


Muffins, $2

Assorted flavors (some seasonal), from The Baker’s Rack.


Giant cookies, $1.50

Assorted flavors (chocolate chip, peanut butter, sugar), from The Baker’s Rack.


Pretzel sticks with peanuts, $2

Dark or milk chocolate with peanuts, caramel, and pretzel sticks. Delicious. From The Baker’s Rack.


Pretzel sticks with caramel, $1.50

Dark or milk chocolate with caramel and pretzel sticks. From The Baker’s Rack. Nut-free.


Fudge, $4

Choose from Coffee, Lavender, Peppermint, and Sea Salt. Made by Austin Homrighaus, co-owner of Starfish and Coffee. Gluten and nut-free.


Vegan Bakery


Granola balls, $3

Varieties include Pomegranate/Nut or Golden Chocolate, created by Brianna Tavares (Sublime Shop, Painesville, OH.)


Happy bar, $3

Vanilla cake meets chocolate chip cookie. Perfect for dunking in your coffee or tea!


Chocolate chip cookies (2-pack), $3

A favorite among vegans and non-vegans alike.


Gluten-free Bakery


French macarons, $3

Our latest offering comes from Painesville’s own Lavender Jones Macarons. These delicacies are everything you could hope for. And each week we’ll feature 2-packs of different imaginative flavors.


Macaroons (orange chocolate), $3.25

These chocolate-dipped coconut confections are the perfect accompaniment to your coffee or tea, especially if you don’t have time for a meal. Made with love in Willowick, OH.


Macaroons (plain), $3

Fluffy yet substantial coconut macaroons. Simple and delicious.


We use spring water from Sunrise Springs (Newbury, OH), and compostable cups/lids/flatware.